EUROPEAN UNION LAW
W.B. Fisch Winter 2006
Assignment #3

[Ch. 3. THE TREATIES AND THE INSTITUTIONS

[B. The Institutions]

 

                        4.  The Court of Justice (http://europa.eu.int/cj/en/index.htm )

Treaty provisions implemented by Statute of Court of Justice


·        composition

o       number and appointment

§        1 MS, 1 judge (Art. 221; Nice: no change)

§        “common accord” of MS gov’ts (Art. 223)

§        6-year terms, renewable (same)

o       the Advocates General: “reasoned submissions on cases” art. 222 (min. 8, additional AG positions by Council on ECJ request; a 9th appointed for a term (‘96 - ‘00) but now back to 8)

o       sessions:  - art. 221 and Statute Art. 16: 3 or 5-judge chambers, 13-judge Grand Chamber (up from 11 in 2004), full court

·        jurisdiction

o       original actions against EC institutions or MS

o       preliminary rulings on referral from MS courts

o       scope of jurisdiction over matters in Pillars 2 and 3

·        Court of First Instance – Art. 225 (Draft Const.: “High Court”)

o       jurisdiction to be determined by unanimous Council decision, but so far no referrals from MS under art. 234 (authorized by Art 225 but not yet implemented); now most actions brought by private persons

o       review by ECJ on law only

o       same number and manner of selection as ECJ judges

·        Specialized Panels – Art. 225a (Nice), Supp pp. 376-7

o       Civil Service Tribunal (est. 2004, constituted 12/12/05)

 

                                    5.  Other Institutions


 

·        Court of Auditors – Arts. 246-248

·        Economic and Social Committee – Art. 257

o       what role should such an institution play?

o       what interests are represented here, that are not necessarily represented in the EP and other major institutions?

·        Committee of the Regions (Maastricht) – Art. 263

o       what role should such a group play in a supranational system?

o       should it have standing to institute ECJ proceedings?

·        .Specialized agencies